So I decided to go through the plethora of Servants in the Fate franchise and organize them based on their stat parameters. The stat parameter chart for Servants is below. Each letter has an assigned value. Thus, each of the six statistics (Strength, Endurance, Agility, Magic, Luck, and Noble Phantasm) does as well.
This list will have the Servants ranked from highest to lowest in terms of their relative stat parameters. I will only be giving the value of all the categories totaled, not what the Servant has in each individual statistic. This is by no means of definitive method of who could defeat who. There are numerous factors that simply cannot be quantified such as Class Skills and Personal Skills, along with other variables that could potentially alter battles like intelligence, tactical knowledge, weapon choices, combat experience, and so on. In addition Noble Phantasms will not be taken into consideration for this list, which can often be game changers. So regardless of what rank a Servant's Noble Phantasm may have it is not calculated into these numbers. Finally, while the "EX" ranking technically means that the stat is "off the chart" for this list I will simply be assigning such rankings the maximum value applicable on the chart itself (which is 100).
Tiamat - 530 Gorgon Medusa - 500 Solomon - 460 Nightingale - 400 Lu Bu - 400 Asterios - 360 Charles Babbage - 360 Quetzalcoatl - 360 Caligula - 340 St. George - 330 Arjuna - 320 Saber Alter - 300 Artoria (Lancer Alter Version) - 300 Gawain - 300 Hercules - 290 Fionn Mac Cumhaill - 280 Achilles - 280 Karna (Master = Jinako) - 280 Artoria (Master = Rin) - 280 Cu Chulainn (Alter) - 280 Ishtar - 270 Thomas Edison - 270 Rama - 270 Genjou Sanzou - 270 Lancelot (Berserker) - 270 Stheno - 260 Bedivere - 260 Fuma Kotaro - 260 Shiki Ryogi (Assassin) - 260 Enkidu - 250 Ozymandias - 250 Shuten Douji - 250 Euryale - 250 Chiron - 250 Ibaraki Douji - 240 Joan Of Arc (Alter) - 240 Orion - 240 Sakata Kintoki - 240 St. Martha - 240 Ushiwakamaru - 240 Lancelot (Saber) - 240 Alexander - 240 Mordred - 230 Mysterious Heroine X - 230 Eric Bloodaxe - 230 Altera - 230 Artoria (Lancer Version) - 220 Gilgamesh (Master = Tokiomi) - 220 Joan Of Arc - 220 Hassan Of Serenity - 220 Brynhildr - 220 Zhuge Liang - 220 Darius III - 220 Edward Teach - 220 Artoria (Master = Kiritsugu) - 210 Siegfried - 210 Astolfo - 210 Chevalier D'Eon - 210 Count Of Monte Cristo - 210 Benkei - 210 Romulus - 210 Hector - 210 Jekyll & Hyde - 210 Medea - 200 Kojiro Sasaki - 200 Diarmuid - 200 Spartacus - 200 Vlad III (Apocrypha) - 200 Francis Drake - 200 Beowulf - 200 Geronimo - 200 Marie Antoinette - 200 Arash - 200 Gilgamesh (Master = Kirei) - 190 Scathach - 190 Shiro Amakusa - 190 Leonardo Da Vinci - 190 Minamoto - 190 Queen Medb - 190 Emiya (Assassin) - 190 Artoria (Master = Shiro) - 180 Karna (Apocrypha) - 180 Robin Hood - 180 Nitocris - 180 Tristan - 180 Shiki Ryogi (Saber) - 180 Fergus Mac Roich - 180 Oda Nobunaga - 180 Vlad III (Berserker) - 180 Mephistopheles - 180 Boudica - 180 Julius Caesar - 180 Nero - 180 Shielder - 170 Shakespeare - 170 Vlad III (Extra) - 170 Leonidas - 170 David - 170 Okita Souji - 170 Gilgamesh (Caster) - 170 Tawara Touta - 170 Cu Chulainn (Lancer) - 160 Medusa (Master = Sakura) - 160 True Assassin - 160 Phantom Of The Opera - 160 Anne Bonny & Mary Read - 160 Nikola Tesla - 160 Cleopatra - 160 Atalanta - 150 Semiramis - 150 Jack The Ripper - 150 Elizabeth Bathory - 150 Paracelcus von Hohenheim - 150 Helena Blavatsky - 150 Jaguar Man - 150 Merlin - 150 King Hassan - 150 Medusa (Master = Shinji) - 140 Hassan Of The Hundred Faces - 140 Gilles (Saber) - 140 Nursery Rhyme - 140 Hans Christian Anderson - 140 Charles-Henri Sanson - 140 Li Shuwen (Lancer) - 140 Li Shuwen (Assassin) - 140 Medusa (Lancer) - 140 Carmilla- 140 Tamamo - 130 Emiya (Archer) - 130 Avicebron - 130 Frankenstein - 120 Cu Chulainn (Caster) - 120 Billy The Kid - 120 Angra Mainyu - 110 Jing Ke - 110 Gilles (Caster) - 90 Kiyohime - 70 Mata Hari- 60
So to summarize Tiamat takes the crown as the one with the highest stat total. If you want to be picky and site how she isn't technically a Servant in the same sense as others then Gorgon Medusa is at the top. Other Servants in the top ten that people might recognize include Solomon, Saber Alter, Artoria (Lancer Alter), Gawain, Arjuna, and Hercules. There were a few others aside from those mentioned that even I wasn't expecting to rank that high. Gilles de Rais, Kiyohime, and Mata Hari end up as the only three Servants with double-digit totals and are the least impressive when considering only stat parameters and nothing else. Enkidu gets bragging rights for having the most balanced stats of any Servant, with a solid "A" in all five. Solomon has possibly the most unbalanced parameters of any Servant, with an "E" rank in two and a ridiculous "A++" in two others. Of course there are several extremely powerful Servants like Gilgamesh, Ozymandias, Merlin, and King Hassan whose capabilities just can't be completely captured on the parameter chart alone given that their stats are rather mediocre compared to some of their peers and the former two rely heavily on their Noble Phantasms (which are usually more than enough to close any gaps in stats).
Dream: Last anime I will be covering is Gankutsuou: Count of Monte Cristo. Will start watching it tomorrow. Not sure how much longer I can keep myself up at this point.
Feb 7, 2020 5:19:21 GMT
Taka: Depending on my energy, I can watched up to 2 AM. Usually with work, I fall asleep on anime series that don't have a lot of action.
Feb 9, 2020 3:24:18 GMT
Master Menos: Finally got out of the fast food job. It was a graceful exit, but to be honest, I'll miss some of those guys. Got a sprained ankle from it since September, so I'll finally focus on healing that back at the family home.
Feb 10, 2020 3:53:27 GMT
HungryWorld: Well if anyone remembers what happened to Pingu in the City, with it being joke 10/10 scored on MAL just to get it into the top 10 anime... well now is Ishuzoku Reviewers' turn. Seems that in response to Funimation's cancel people boosted the score hard.
Feb 11, 2020 2:11:38 GMT
Taka: What? That sounds so weird.
Feb 11, 2020 5:36:23 GMT
Master Menos: It's damn awesome to be honest. It shot to 1st Place!
Feb 11, 2020 6:31:08 GMT
Dream: On the subject of MAL, it looks like the admin are planning to tweak their scoring system for titles to reduce the likelihood of voters artificially inflating the ranking of certain titles.
Feb 13, 2020 22:47:26 GMT
Master Menos: My V-Day present will be belated this year because I "Had some trouble with ol' Johnny." (That's your hint.)
Feb 15, 2020 4:17:13 GMT
Dream: The joys of adulthood. Joking aside, plan to at least attempt to wrap up Gankutsuou sometime early to mid next week so I can get done with my Funi voted titles. Afterward, not doing any more voting for a while considering how long this had been taking.
Feb 15, 2020 16:50:30 GMT
Dream: Done with Gankutsuou. Will be working to get a review up for it by sometime tonight.
Feb 16, 2020 20:57:26 GMT
Taka: Great job, Dream! I should do some reviews, too.
Feb 17, 2020 5:24:39 GMT
Dream: Looks like MAL's currently down due to the site getting hit by a major denial-of-service attack, just as a heads up.
Feb 18, 2020 17:55:23 GMT
Taka: I added 2 polls tonight. Also, I wonder why MAL was down. Crunchyroll also had it, too.
Feb 20, 2020 4:05:24 GMT
Dream: Not sure about Crunchyroll. For MAL, the DoS attacks may have been retaliation by those who dabbled into manipulating the site's scoring system for certain anime titles. The admin on MAL announced they would be overhauling the system to prevent said...
Feb 20, 2020 13:42:15 GMT
Dream: ...manipulation last week.
Feb 20, 2020 13:42:45 GMT